TOLL and x402-list
What each publishes about x402 endpoints, row by row. x402-list describes itself as a directory of x402 services with probes, badges, on-chain volume and a change log. TOLL is an index and a measurement series built from two registries.
Operator, as stated: Named on the site as Cosimo Miccolis, an individual in Italy, who is also its data controller. TOLL's own column is written from its method page and the live index; the listed count is as of the last pull.
| dimension | x402-list, as checked | TOLL | where they differ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sources | x402-listServices are "submitted" by operators or users, or "imported" from the x402 Bazaar and from x402scan; imports "signal discovery, not endorsement". | TOLLThe Coinbase CDP discovery catalogue and the Binance B402 bazaar, pulled every six hours and deduplicated on canonical URL. No submissions. | differencex402-list accepts submissions and imports from two indexes; TOLL reads two registries and takes no submissions. |
| Listings counted | x402-list680 listed services, of which 642 in the payment-ready tier and 14 in the verified tier. | TOLL16,167 endpoints listed at the last pull. | differenceDifferent units: x402-list counts services it has probed, TOLL counts endpoints the registries list. |
| Usage figures | x402-listSettlement volume measured on-chain, independently of any registry, through HyperSync for EVM chains and Helius for Solana: 5,452,645 settlements, US$117,344 in USDC and 4,725 distinct buyers over 30 days across 516 services, attributed by settler address. | TOLLThe registry's own per-endpoint counters, calls and unique payers over the trailing 30 days, snapshotted every six hours and never overwritten. No on-chain measurement yet. | differencex402-list measures on-chain settlement; TOLL republishes the registry's counters and says so on every figure. |
| Reachability and conformance | x402-listUptime probes every 5 to 15 minutes with rolling 24-hour, 7-day, 30-day and 90-day windows, raw checks kept 30 days; a 14-check compliance list with letter grades; badge tiers verified, payment-ready and listed; payment-ready is withdrawn after 7 days of failing probes. | TOLLOne sweep a day through Coinbase's validate endpoint, sent the declared HTTP method; 25 named checks stored per observation; states pass, fail, malformed, legacy v1, no method and unobserved; uptime over 7, 30 and 90 days from those sweeps. No score, no badge. | differencex402-list probes up to 288 times a day and grades; TOLL sweeps once a day and publishes a state, never a score. |
| Change history | x402-list10,494 change events since 24 July 2026: 1,095 payout-address rotations, 838 price moves and 8,561 schema changes, from fingerprinting the full accepts array on every probe; browsable across 420 pages and as JSON. | TOLLPresence events since 10 September 2026, the payment options as declared since 12 September 2026 at 20:44 UTC, every validation and every counter snapshot, all append-only. Confirmed delistings in the Atom feed. | differenceTwo kinds of record. On 14 September TOLL's published calls-to-payers correlation was found to have moved from 0.11 to 0.40 in four days. Answering why needed the counters of every endpoint at every past snapshot: the set carrying both counters on 10 September was reconstructed after the question was asked and the figure recomputed across only those endpoints, which located the cause in one endpoint (/ledger/correlation). A log of changes records that a value moved; it does not keep the rows that question needs. x402-list's log records that a value moved, per probe, since 24 July. TOLL's series records what every value was at each stated time, every six hours since 10 September, which is what lets a page be pinned to a snapshot and cited. |
| Method | x402-listA methodology page of 13 sections, covering badge rules and decay, volume attribution, self-payment disclosure, data sources, uptime and compliance scoring. | TOLLOne method page, with versioned rules (burst rule v1, delisting confirmation v1, category rules v1) and a dated changelog. | differenceBoth publish a method; TOLL's carries rule version numbers and a changelog of every change. |
| Data access | x402-listA REST API at /api/v1 with an OpenAPI specification, a JSON version of the change feed, and llms-full.txt. | TOLLJSON at /api/v1 with the snapshot stamp and rule version in every body, an Atom feed, llms.txt, CC BY 4.0. | differenceComparable; TOLL's bodies carry the snapshot stamp so a figure can be reproduced later. |
| Right of reply and disputes | x402-listAn email address for "data disputes or delisting"; owner self-service metadata updates with domain proof; paid suggestions at a US$0.10 x402 payment. | TOLLA free public form on every page, no account and no token; every report and reply is published unedited with its outcome; a reply signed with the named wallet is marked verified. No paid path. | differencex402-list handles disputes by email and offers a paid suggestion path; TOLL publishes every report and its outcome on the page. |
| Citation permanence | x402-listNot found on the site as checked. | TOLLEvery Ledger and endpoint page has a pinned form at a snapshot stamp that never changes, and a citation block with the pinned URL. | differenceTOLL keeps every snapshot and pins pages to them; no equivalent was found on x402-list. |
| Listing on request | x402-listA submission page for operators; imported listings are marked as such. | TOLLNone. TOLL indexes what the registries list and nothing else; a delisted endpoint keeps its page. | differencex402-list lists on request; TOLL does not. |
| Licence | x402-listCC BY 4.0, with attribution to x402-list.com. | TOLLCC BY 4.0. | differenceThe same licence. |
| Operator | x402-listAn individual, named on the site. | TOLLOne individual with no position in the ecosystem it measures; takes no money and lists nobody for pay (see /about). | differenceBoth are run by one person; TOLL states that it holds no position in what it measures. |
The other comparisons: TOLL and x402scan · TOLL and agentic.market. The Coinbase Bazaar is TOLL's source, not a comparison; what it publishes and what TOLL adds is on the method page.
Cite this page
This page carries the date its facts were checked, 2026-09-13; its live URL is the stable one. Data reuse is under CC BY 4.0 (terms).
Plain text
TOLL, "TOLL and x402-list, what each publishes". https://tollindex.com/vs/x402-list. Accessed [access date].
BibTeX
@misc{toll-vs-x402-list-2026-09-15,
author = {TOLL},
title = {TOLL and x402-list, what each publishes},
howpublished = {\url{https://tollindex.com/vs/x402-list}},
year = {2026},
month = {9},
note = {Frozen at its last observation, 2026-09-15 16:58 UTC. Accessed [access date].}
}Corrections and replies about this page
Anyone, x402-list included, can correct a cell here. Corrections are published with their outcome and the table is updated with a new check date.
None yet. Anything submitted through the form below is published here with its outcome.